There is no way to dress this one up, and Mike McCarthy did not try. "Disappointed in the performance, clearly," the Steelers' head coach said after Sunday night's 38-18 loss at Paycor Stadium. "We were beaten decisively." He was right on both counts. The Cincinnati Bengals (7-2) won their fifth straight game, took sole possession of first place in the AFC North, and split the season series with Pittsburgh (6-3) — and for most of the night at Paycor Stadium, it was not close.
The game was gone by halftime
Joe Burrow put on one of the great passing performances ever seen against a Pittsburgh defense. Burrow completed 35 of 44 passes for 409 yards and four touchdowns, and he did the bulk of the damage early — 302 of those yards came in the first half as Cincinnati built a 24-3 halftime lead. Ja'Marr Chase caught 11 passes for 231 yards, and running back Chase Brown added 82 scrimmage yards and two receiving touchdowns. In all, the Bengals outgained the Steelers 484-222 and held the ball for 35:09 to Pittsburgh's 24:51.
Former Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin, working the game for NBC in his first season as a broadcaster, was just as blunt on the postgame show, pointing to breakdowns in so many areas and saying his old team got smashed. When both the current coach and the man who held the job for 19 years land on the same word, there is not much left to argue about.
Rodgers' worst night as a Steeler
Aaron Rodgers opened the game 0-for-7 passing — the worst start to a game of his career — and never found a rhythm against a Cincinnati defense that sacked him three times. He finished 15-for-29 for just 143 yards, his lowest output of the season, before being lifted late for backup Mason Rudolph. Pittsburgh did not reach the end zone until the fourth quarter.
The two late scores were the only bright spots on the scoresheet. DK Metcalf caught a touchdown and added the two-point conversion himself — the rare "octopus" — to cut it to 31-11, but Samaje Perine answered almost immediately for Cincinnati. Pat Freiermuth, who played through an illness that had him listed as questionable on Saturday, then hauled in a 27-yard touchdown with 7:19 left, fighting between two defenders and extending the ball over the goal line. He finished with two catches for 35 yards. It made the final 38-18 — a score, for what it is worth on a rough night, that had never occurred before in NFL history, becoming the league's 1,100th unique final score.
The injury bill
The loss was not the only damage. Left guard Mason McCormick suffered what appeared to be a serious right ankle injury in the second quarter, on the play where Rodgers was sacked on third down, and his status is the biggest question hanging over this week. Safety DeShon Elliott never got to play at all — he injured a knee in pregame warmups and was ruled out less than two hours before kickoff, leaving rookie Robert Spears-Jennings to take on a bigger role against Burrow. Edge rusher Nick Herbig was also checked by trainers in the first half before returning.
There was one piece of genuinely good news: defensive lineman Derrick Harmon returned from injured reserve for his first game since Week 4 and said afterward that he felt good, even as he acknowledged the defensive performance has to be better. Wide receiver Michael Pittman Jr. remains on injured reserve with his foot injury. Pittsburgh releases its first injury report of the week on Wednesday, and the McCormick and Elliott updates will set the tone for everything that follows.
What it means, and what is next
The standings math is simple and unforgiving. Cincinnati is 7-2 and alone in first. Pittsburgh is 6-3, a game back, and the head-to-head tiebreaker is now a wash after the teams split — the Steelers won the first meeting 30-27 in September. The four-game winning streak that carried Pittsburgh out of its bye is over, and the questions that were easy to wave away during it — Can this secondary hold up against an elite quarterback? Can this offense function when Rodgers is under pressure from the first snap? — are now the whole conversation.
The good news, such as it is, is the schedule. Next up is the Battle of Pennsylvania: the Steelers visit the Philadelphia Eagles (2-7) on Sunday, November 22, at Lincoln Financial Field, with kickoff flexed to 1:00 p.m. ET on CBS. Philadelphia has lost seven straight, is coming off its bye, and has turned to backup quarterback Joe Milton with Jalen Hurts sidelined. Oddsmakers still believe in the rebound — Pittsburgh opened as a 4.5-point road favorite.
History, however, is on the other side. The Steelers have not won in Philadelphia since 1965, and the Eagles have won the last 11 meetings between the teams played in Philadelphia, including a 27-13 win in the most recent matchup on December 15, 2024.
Projection (labeled as such, not a fact): early Week 11 projections favor Pittsburgh in a bounce-back spot — one published projection has it Steelers 23, Eagles 16 — but that projection assumes the offensive line holds together without McCormick and the secondary tightens up after giving up 409 passing yards. Both assumptions are unproven until Wednesday's injury report and Sunday's kickoff. What is certain is this: a team that was beaten decisively in Cincinnati cannot afford a second flat performance in Philadelphia, not with first place already gone and the Bengals showing no sign of slowing down.
It is finally gameday, and the picture is almost complete. Tonight at 8:20 p.m. ET at Paycor Stadium in Cincinnati (NBC and Peacock), the Pittsburgh Steelers (6-2) visit the Cincinnati Bengals (6-2) on Sunday Night Football with sole possession of first place…
One day out, the Pittsburgh Steelers have the cleanest injury picture they have carried into a big game all season — and one Saturday decision left to make.
Pittsburgh (6-2) visits the Cincinnati Bengals (6-2) on Sunday, November 15, at 8:20 p.m. ET at Pay…
Two days out, the news the Pittsburgh Steelers needed is arriving on the practice field. On Sunday, November 15, at 8:20 p.m. ET at Paycor Stadium (NBC and Peacock), the Steelers (6-2) visit the Cincinnati Bengals (6-2) with sole possession of first place in …