Sponsored

24 Hours That Shape the Winter: Lowe's Answer, a Silver Slugger Watch and the Rule 5 Crunch All Land Tuesday

Pirates

The Pittsburgh Pirates' offseason has been mostly talk since the GM Meetings in Las Vegas. On Tuesday, the talk ends and the answers start — three of them, all in the same afternoon, and all of them will shape what the 2027 club looks like before the December 1 labor deadline starts freezing the winter. ## 4 p.m.: Brandon Lowe's qualifying-offer answer Lowe has until 4 p.m. ET Tuesday to accept or decline the one-year, $23.15 million qualifying offer the Pirates extended on November 2. He is one of seven players still holding a qualifying offer — eight were issued, but Milwaukee's Jake Bauers came off the board by signing a four-year deal with Boston, leaving Lowe alongside Randy Arozarena, David Bednar, Ryan Jeffers, Adrián Morejón, Trevor Rogers and Seiya Suzuki. The expectation around the league remains that Lowe declines and tests a market where a multiyear deal should be waiting. His 2026 case is strong: a .260 average with 35 home runs, 96 RBI and an .824 OPS, leading all major league second basemen in homers — and his 33 home runs hit while playing second base shattered the Pirates' positional record. General manager Ben Cherington told reporters at the GM Meetings that talks with Lowe's camp have been good and ongoing since the end of the season, and that the club wants him back. Two things are worth remembering whatever Tuesday brings. Declining the offer does not close the door on a return — Pittsburgh could still negotiate a separate deal. And if Lowe signs elsewhere, the Pirates receive draft-pick compensation. What they would not receive is a replacement for the middle-of-the-order power that helped carry them to 82-80 and their first winning season since 2018. Nick Gonzales is the in-house fallback most often mentioned at second base, and that drop-off is exactly why Cherington would rather keep the incumbent. ## Same day: a Silver Slugger that would end an 11-year drought Tuesday is also when the 2026 Silver Slugger winners are announced, and Lowe is a finalist at second base. A win would make him the first Pirate to take home a Silver Slugger since Andrew McCutchen in 2015 — an 11-year drought that says plenty about the lineups Pittsburgh has run out over the last decade. His competition is real. Milwaukee's Brice Turang hit .268 with a .366 on-base percentage, 21 home runs and 100 RBI for the World Series champion Brewers, was an NL MVP finalist, and has already finished ahead of Lowe on the All-MLB team and for the NL Gold Glove at second. But the Silver Slugger is an offensive award, and on pure offense Lowe's power season stands above the field. It would be a bittersweet headline if Pittsburgh celebrates its first Silver Slugger in more than a decade on the same afternoon its winner turns down $23.15 million — but that is the day the Pirates may be about to have. ## 6 p.m.: the Rule 5 protection crunch Two hours after the qualifying-offer deadline, at 6 p.m. ET, teams must set their 40-man rosters to protect prospects from the Rule 5 Draft, scheduled for December 9. Pittsburgh's roster currently sits at 38, which means only two open spots before someone has to come off — and there are more than two prospects worth a serious conversation. The name at the center of it is catcher Axiel Plaz, the club's No. 7 prospect per MLB Pipeline, who hit .305/.389/.513 with 18 home runs and 74 RBI at High-A Greensboro and threw out 37 percent of attempted base stealers. Protecting him is the obvious baseball call — and the complicated one, because the Pirates already carry three catchers on the 40-man, including Henry Davis, who hit just .172/.272/.313 in 2026. Adding Plaz almost certainly means four catchers do not stay, and what Pittsburgh does here will say a lot about how much patience is left for Davis. Beyond Plaz, the candidates include outfielder Lonnie White Jr., finally healthy and coming off a .270/.376/.520 season with 26 home runs split between Greensboro and Altoona; right-hander Derek Diamond, who went 5-0 with a 3.14 ERA at Triple-A Indianapolis and fits the profile of relievers other clubs poach in this draft; and slugger Tony Blanco Jr., whose 25 home runs at Greensboro came with real swing-and-miss risk. The hardest call may be 2022 first-round pick Termarr Johnson, who hit .199 in his first year at Indianapolis and suffered a season-ending knee injury in August — a year ago his protection looked automatic, and now it is a genuine debate. One more wrinkle: with the CBA expiring at 11:59 p.m. ET on December 1 and a lockout expected, even the Rule 5 Draft itself is not guaranteed — it was cancelled during the 2021-22 lockout. ## And then Friday The week does not end Tuesday. Friday is the non-tender deadline, with 11 Pirates arbitration-eligible, and outfielder Akil Baddoo — claimed off waivers from Milwaukee on November 2, the club's lone addition so far — widely viewed as the most likely casualty if roster room is needed. The stakes for getting this week right are not abstract. FanGraphs' ZiPS projections, published this week, already see the Pirates as a Wild Card contender in 2027 as currently constructed — a projection, not a promise, but a sign of how far the 82-win club has moved the expectations. Tuesday's three answers will decide whether that construction still includes the best power-hitting second baseman in baseball last season, and how many of the prospects behind him Pittsburgh manages to keep.
♥ 0 likes👁 6 reads this weekLog in to like or save this article.

Related coverage

Keep reading — more published coverage from SportsNat, closest matches first.

Skenes Is Staying, Griffin Is the Future — Now the Pirates Have to Build Like It

Pirates

The clearest news out of the GM Meetings in Las Vegas is what the Pittsburgh Pirates are not doing. They are not trading Paul Skenes this winter, and they are not treating Konnor Griffin as just another promising rookie. The core, in other words, is settled. …

Three Days to Decision Day: Lowe's Answer, Rule 5 Protection and a Left-Handed Shopping List

Pirates

The Pittsburgh Pirates do not have all winter. They barely have all month — and the next three days will tell us more about the 2027 club than the last three weeks have. Pittsburgh finished 2026 at 82-80, third in the NL Central, an 11-win improvement and …

No Game Until Thursday: Penguins' Practice Week Is About Fixing the Second Period

Penguins

There is no Penguins game tonight, and that is exactly the story. Pittsburgh does not play again until Thursday, November 19, when the St. Louis Blues visit PPG Paints Arena at 7 p.m. ET — and head coach Dan Muse gets something this team has not had much of l…

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Log in or sign up free to join the conversation.